Is the Crucifix too Catholic? – What Does This Mean?

From the earliest days of the Christian faith, Christians have used the sign of the cross to remember the sufferings and death of her Lord and Savior. Not only did they use the sign to identify each other and during worship, they hung artistic versions of the cross. On the wall of a large room in Herculaneum, destroyed with Pompeii in 79 A.D., a cross-shaped mark was found in one of their walls.

Beginning at the end of the Fifth Century (400s AD), representations of the body of the dying Jesus began to appear on crosses. These became known as crucifixes. Churches throughout Christianity used crucifixes universally. It wasn’t until the 16th Century (1500s AD) that anyone objected to them. During the Reformation, the Reformed and Anabaptist traditions objected to them, thinking that crucifixes and Christian art in general were idols. Luther and the Lutheran tradition rejected this charge, contending that such depictions were an aid to devotion. No one was worshiping them. They were inspired by their art and their imagination turned to the events they represented.

So Lutherans continue use crucifixes until this day. Many of the great artists and musicians since that day were Lutherans and used their talents to enhance their churches and worship. Only in the last century, and in the United States, when Lutherans began to worship in English, did this begin to change. Their friends, families and neighbors accused them of being “too catholic,” not realizing that they were out of step with a sixteen hundred year old practice of the Christian Church.

There is, however, a deeper theological issue. When asked why they feel the empty cross is better than a crucifix, our non-Lutheran friends often object that Jesus did not stay on the cross, but is now risen from the dead. They think we need to focus on the Resurrection. Yet this is not what St. Paul tells the Corinthians, who said, among other things, ” I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified.” (1 Corinthians 2:2) The focus of Christian preaching is to be on the cross. The crucifixes do just that. Christ is indeed risen from the dead, but he retained his wounds eternally to proclaim that sacrifice. And because he is risen, that sacrifice is now wherever Christians gather in his name.

So, far from apologizing for crucifixes, Lutherans are proud of them. For they are a symbol, pointing to the sacrifice that won our salvation. They remind us of the Lamb-who-was-slain for our sins and sins of the whole world.