Encore Post: “That’s Catholic!” you may hear someone say when they see a Lutheran make the sign of the cross, see a crucifix hanging in the sanctuary of a Lutheran church, a pastor wearing a clerical collar or some other traditional practice they’ve not seen Lutherans do. What they’re thinking is this means the Lutheran in question is acting like a Roman Catholic. They are often unaware that Lutherans have had these practices since the time of the Reformation or that the word catholic did not originally refer to the Christian tradition headed by the Pope. The word catholic has been used since the days of the early church to mean the whole Christian Church.
The word catholic is from the Greek word καθολικός (literally “according to the whole”) and means “universal.” So, if we wanted to be sarcastic, we could answer the objection “that’s catholic,” “Why, yes! The whole church does it!” The early church would use the phrase: “catholic church” to mean the invisible church. When someone wanted to talk about the faith of the whole church and not just a single congregation or region, they would call it the “catholic faith.”
Soon the word was used to separate false teachings and false teachers from orthodox teachings and leaders. The true faith was called the “catholic” or “orthodox” faith. False teachings were called heresies (literally “other teachings”) and the groups that promoted it schisms (literally “divisions”) At the time of the Reformation, Luther’s opponents quickly charged him and his associates with not being “catholic” but heretical. They labeled them Lutherans as an insult (meaning followers of Luther and not Christ) and themselves as Catholic. From the very beginning Luther and Lutheran theologians defended themselves by saying they were the true catholics, teaching the orthodox faith which was taught and practiced from the beginning. As you might guess, they did not win this argument, even though they were right.
You will occasionally run into the word in Lutheran circles even today. You will sometimes see it in the creeds — especially the Apostles’ Creed, which reads in Latin and Greek (translated) “one holy, catholic and apostolic church.” Martin Luther changed the word in the Apostles’ Creed to “Christian” to avoid confusion. Theologians will still use the term from time to time when emphasizing that we believe and teach what the church has always believed. So, don’t panic if you are asked to confess that you believe in the catholic faith — because you do!
Rev. Robert E. Smith
Concordia Theological Seminary
Fort Wayne, Indiana
©2019 Robert E. Smith. All rights reserved. Permission granted to copy, share and display freely for non-commercial purposes. Direct all other rights and permissions inquiries to cosmithb@gmail.com
Thank you so much for the blog. We tend to for get, or may have never known, many of the concepts.
I often say I am an Augsburg Catholic.
Then you do not really exist. The Augsburg Confession was condemned as refuted by the Catholic Church in 1530 and that (continued) condemnation of Luther’s Reformation as heresy has never been overturned, nor is it likely to be. There are no “Augsburg Catholics.”
I’m not quite sure who you’re replying to, but, OK…
To David Drew’s çomment, but apparently it didn’t come out that way. Your post is excellent, although it doesn’t overcome the nearly constant confusion of Lutheran ecclesiology even as taught by some Lutheran theologians today, who seem to agree with Catholics rather than the Lutheran Confessions (as well as the Bible) on what is the true Church and therefore what defines something as Catholic (or Christian).